The food was heaven too. All I remember were the rolls. I'm sure there was turkey, stuffing, the works, but the Rolls. ahhh. I remember sneaking through the kitchen and swiping them off the pans. Warm and buttery. Maybe that is why I can't remember the rest of the meal. I was full before we even sat down.
If you make rolls for your Thanksgiving dinner, good for you. Keep it up. If you don't, Please try it. It is not that hard and I promise, it makes the meal. Brown and serve just don't cut it.
Here are the step by steps.

Grandma Cutler's Thanksgiving Rolls
2 cups warm water2 packages yeast (that is 4 1/2 tsp)
Let that sit and get nice and foamy.
Add 1/3 cup sugar
1/3 cup shortening (I like butter flavored. But then, you'll see, I add butter every chance I get)
1 tsp salt
1 egg
Mix this all together. It will be sloshy and the shortening might just be glops. That is ok. Now start adding flour. You'll end up with between 4 and 6 cups. Nice window huh. You don't want it too sticky because you'll have to roll it out, but if is too sticky, you'll just add flour while you roll it out. All good. Don't be afraid. Ideally you want to add just enough flour that it pulls away from the bowl. Let the mixer run for about 5 minutes. (I think I added too much this time, but the whole pan was gone in about 15 minutes so it must have been ok.)
Next, cover it up and go read or surf or swaddle and rock your baby for about an hour (let it double in size.)

Don' t you just love how my couch and dishtowels match? Comment if you bought the same sofa 13 years ago in Provo. :)
Next you're going to roll it out. Go for about 1/2 inch thick... Plenty of flour on your harvest gold counter top. What? Yours aren't Harvest Gold? How sad for you. They are so cheery.
When it comes time to shape your rolls you have lots of options. Grandma Cutler just made nice round circles, then dipped them in melted butter (lovely orange Ikea bowl above) and folded them in half. They don't stay folded well when they rise, but that is ok. You can slice them (Using your pizza cutter is a must) in triangles and roll them like crescent rolls, or make 3 round balls and pop them in a muffin tin. All great options, just remember to douse them with melted butter. For knot rolls, slice into about 1/2 inch strips, maybe 6 inches? I dunno, you'll be able to tell when you are doing it.
I think I prefer knot rolls. They are beautiful, but I like them mostly because of the playful banter with the kids.
"What are you making mom?"
"Knot Rolls."
"Yes they are."
"No, they are Knot."
"Uh huh. I can see them, right there."
"Nope, those are knot rolls"
You get the picture, it goes on as long as it takes to shape them all.
Here are the various shapes, then before the final rising, after the rising and lastly ready for eating.Ok, back to the recipe. You aren't done yet. Brush them liberally with melted butter. Cover them and let them rise again-- maybe 15- 20 minutes, or until you can't wait any longer. Bake at 400* for 10ish minutes. (Less if you have a lovely"broken in" (black) pan like mine. I lurve my pan)
So, there. Your bossing for the day. Make a batch of rolls. (You'll probably want to double it. Just think of the left over turkey sandwiches. mmmmm.) (Oh, but if you do double it, move it to a bigger bowl for the first rising... trust me.)

14 comments:
This looks easy. My recipe calls for scalded milk and I hate that extra step.
Yum! If I don't do this for Thanksgiving, I will do it for a Sunday dinner sometime. Great story and recipe! Thanks!
Okay, I don't cook, usually, so I was sceptical, but this looks like an ideal way to spend an hour with the kids. Maybe we will play Settlers of Catan while the rolls rise.
I love your couch and dish towel,and I love your banter with the kids.
Dear sisters,
Please peer pressure Emily into making rolls for Thanksgiving.
I would do it but I've got kind of pudgy fingers and I don't think I could make very good twisty knots with that floppy dough.
Thanks,
Joe
I do the knot roll banter with my kids too (because you told us about it years ago) and they keep it going for a long time. It never gets old.
Henry looks like he is 3 years old in that swaddle picture! Honestly, I have friends whose 3 year olds are smaller than Henry.
I make the same rolls in advance and freeze them before they raise. Then you simply let them defrost on Thanksgiving day and bake them up fresh, no mess and they taste just the same! I have done this many times. I do it with cinnamon rolls too. Such a time saver.
I loved this post. How do you knot just eat all the rolls the minute they come out of the oven? I am totally going to do this, because reading your post made me knot afraid of it. Robin said I might be able to make them in advance. Robin, or someone else who knows, at what point in the recipe can I freeze the knot rolls?
Melissa, I love your photos. I could eat those rolls right this minute. I am afraid that they wil knot even reach the table at our house. And the couch made me laugh because our favorite neighbors in wymount bought that couch and loveseat and it was a big deal! I was a little jealous because we could knot afford matching furniture. :)
Someone, stop me.
Okay, Robin, sorry I didn't read your comment before posting mine. So let me be clear on this--you let the dough rise, then form the rolls, and then freeze them. Another question--how do you know what time to pull the rolls out to thaw? I don't want overly risen rolls, nor do I want flat rolls. The timing. It's all about the timing.
Sally, do knot freak out about this. It's knot that hard. Form the rolls, paint them with melted butter, cover and freeze. They will need about 5-8 hours to defrost and rise (depending on how warm your kitchen is and how big you make the rolls).
Double the recipe and make the rolls today, make a few pans. cook one for today. Freeze the rest. Tomorrow take out one of the pans and test and see how long it takes to defrost and rise. There! You have your times! And 2 days worth of rolls, and rolls for Thanksgiving! So easy, so good!
You will knot regret it!
OK girls,
I have to tell you that I love having somewhere to go every day...an escape. Thanks for the bossin', thanks for the smilin', thanks for the good clean fun. Off I go to Knot make rolls.
when they are frozen hard, put the rolls in a ziplock bag so you can free up your pan & make more!
when they are frozen hard, put the rolls in a ziplock bag so you can free up your pan & make more!
Geez, mom is so bossy, she had to say her bit twice!
I made them today!
DELICIOUS!
And I feel so domestic. I froze most of them and I am going to follow Robin's plan and make some tomorrow from frozen so I'll know how long that takes.
Since we will have a billion people here for thanksgiving and everyone loves rolls, I am going to make another batch soon so I can have tons for our turkey dinner and the next day.
Thank you Melissa for the post! You really inspired me to actually do it.
I've never been much of a baker - I'd rather spend my time cooking. But this fall I have had the baking bug...cookies, sweet breads, pies, etc. I've been experimenting with different roll recipes I've found on the internet...with no luck until today!
The second pan just came out of the oven and "OH, MY...!"
FABULOUS!!!!
They are perfect and will be making an appearance at Thanksgiving and Christmas this year.
THANK YOU!
Mandy
Post a Comment